Buckhorn Supper Club: A Classic Wisconsin Supper Club Experience

The BEST kept secret in southern WI!! Come for the food, stay for the sunsets! This place is INCREDIBLE! The food is to die for, the drinks are fabulous, the ambiance is true “WI supper club” vibes, the view is beautiful & the staff is EXCELLENT! The prime rib is like biting into a satin pillowcase, easily some of the most tender & delicious prime rib I’ve ever had! Our bartenders Sarah & Maggie were absolutely FANTASTIC & our server Arturo was SUPERB! We will be back again & again!

A very busy restaurant, I strongly encourage making a reservation. We went on a Saturday night, they had live music (which was good). I did make a reservation, and we ended up waiting over half an hour to get our table. We ordered the tenderloin crostini appetizer (very pepper forward), lobster tail, ribeye with mushrooms, cheesy potato bacon soup, pink squirrel after dinner drink along with homemade pecan pie. All of it was delicious! The meal also included a warm basket of fresh baked rolls, butter, breadsticks, and a delicious cheese spread! The lighting inside is dim, so the photos are not great.

My family chose this spot to celebrate our anniversary and I’m glad they did! The food was wonderful - I had the prime rib, French onion soup and the starter bread that was a pretzel bun with beer cheese on the side. It was all very flavorful and the prime rib was a perfect medium-rare. The indoors was charming with a frozen-in-time look with some modern touches, and the view of the lake was beautiful.

We went for the lobster boil and had a great time. The lobster and the items served with it were fantastic! The service through out the meal was the best we have ever had! We never had to wait to have to get more wine, water, food, or have our plates and the discarded lobster shells cleared. The staff went above and beyond to make you feel welcome and taken care of.

Really love the atmosphere here! Our waitress was very pleasant and attentive. However, they had a decent looking tap beer selection judging by the tap handles but upon ordering they told us they weren't serving any tap beer tonight. The bottled beer selection was just a mix of standard domestic options. We weren't offered an option for inside or outside so I suppose we should have asked, thankfully got a good window seat. I had the Mahi special which was ok and my girlfriend had perch which was great! Portion size was good, but prices a little high.

I have never had better service, better food, or just better everything, Trey our server was phenomenal!! We had great conversation with him from food to accounting, school rivalries to career choices. Buckhorn Supper Club truly defines what the Wisconsin Supper Club experience is all about!!! Never miss a chance to come to dine, drink, or hang out here!!!!! Simply Amazing!!!!!!

Very good supper club, it checked all the boxes. The bar is great and the dining area is a fantastic throwback. We loved the atmosphere and really enjoyed our meal! The patio area was really nice but unfortunately some weather was moving in and we could only enjoy it for a few minutes. Oh and they make a fine old fashioned!

This is a great supper club. The atmosphere is unique and the restaurant is right on the lake. My table had a great view. My server was polite and attentive. The brandy old fashioned was delicious. The food was exquisite.